Friday, March 7, 2008

health care

http://www.angelfire.com/pa/sergeman/issues/healthcare/socialized.html

I remember this was brought up briefly in one of our classes recently, the issue of universal healthcare. The guy who wrote this article isn't a fan, and I was wondering what you guys think about it. From what I can tell, the theory behind UHC resembles the communistic viewpoint of everybody helping everyone else, helping the poor at the extent of the rich, etc. Obviously, those who can afford healthcare without help will hate this policy, but the poor will love it. One problem with it that I can see is that the quality of healthcare will go down, as capitalist competition goes out the window. Again, any comments from more knowledgeable people (which I'm sure there are) are welcome.

5 comments:

Vicky said...

I agree with your comments about universal health care. If there is no competition, there is no incentive for health care to improve. There is no incentive for people to go into the R & D end of things and develop new treatments and drugs either. I'm in favor of more affordable health care, but the government needs to ensure that competition is still in place to ensure that the quality of care will continue to rise. I remember Swantz talking in Government about how many Canadians come to the US for health care, because while their's is free, it also sucks. Just my two cents.
Plus, I don't want the government making decisions about my health care. They could use the line (as I do with my mother). "I'm paying for it therefore, I get what I want." I should be able to choose my doctor and treatment plan free of government interference.

Tanvirkamal said...

Alright, so I am a fan of some of the socialist ideals althought I do believe in a more democratic form of ruling. But from what I can see, it is better to have universal health care because the poor make up the bulk of the population and if they are spending more money on health care because they cannot afford a good insurance company's benefits. If they have a little hike in tax for the sake of decent health care, they will have more money to spend on the economy and then things will get better. Health care wouldn't be free, it would have to improve because of pressure from the government so it can lower the taxes and make things cheaper for people. Canada has free health care, and even though it may be a little bit behind us, it is still on a high level and the doctors are still rich as hell. Cuba is communist but their health care system is phenominal still. So why is such a powerful country like the USA still behind? Provide universal health care and people will be more healthy and have more of a drive to do work.

JoelleBender said...

I understand where you are coming from Phil, but I disagree. You mentioned that the quality of care would decline; that, however, is not necessarily the case. There will be a slight decline in competition, but not much. It is true that companies will no longer have to compete with each other in terms of prices, but they will stil have to compete to get patients to their establishment. The extent of personable staff and extras is what will be sold to patients while looking for a provider. Universal health care will does take from the rich and give to the poor, but so does the system we have now, it's just not so blantantly obvious. Those with little money who cannot afford health care often wait until the last possible minute before going to see a doctor about a problem they have in the hopes that it will heal on its own and they won't have to pay for anything. However, when it doesn't heal these people are sometimes left with life-threatening ailments that require hospitalization. With no insurance these people cannot pay for their hospital stay. The money for the stay and (if serious enough) operations come from taxes; taxes that the rich put more money into than the poor. By letting injuries get to the point of hospitalization the expense of treating the symptom in exponentially more expensive than if one were to pay for preventative treatments or a treatment at an earlier stage. With universal health care, these earlier treatments would be taken care of. Also, with so many non-covered patients waiting until the last minute, their condition is more likely to be chronic, therefore requiring lifetime care (another expensive treatment). With universal health care people will be able to get treatment when they need it. This allows for the lower class community to spend money elsewhere, as well as ensures that they will not be out of work due to untreatable health problems. Canada and the UK have successfully switched to universal health care, and their new and innovative care and technology continues to rival that of the United States. Universal healthcare would do no harm to our nation, it would only help those who are currently unfortunate enough to lack insurance.

JoelleBender said...

Wow, I had no idea that ended up that long. Sorry!

KM said...

Wow, great comments!

Flat bottom line is...most people in the US are not content without choices. And they do not like their taxes going up.

With those two things, I'm predicting that it will be a long time before you see UHC in the US.

But that, of course, is jmo. :)